DaysTalk

29 Nov, 2009

Melanie is Carly’s Daughter – Not Mia (speculation)

Posted by: admin In: Uncategorized

By James Plouf

crystal-mollyAll signs are pointing to Melanie being the long lost daughter of Carly. Why? Because Mia is way to obvious of an outcome for this storyline. What would be really great is if Nicole was Mia’s mom. That would make Grace her granddaughter.

So, the biological father of Melanie could be Daniel. Carly got pregnant when she was at some medical conference. Fast forward. I’m not sure why Trent would agree to adopt the baby. It would explain why he treated Melanie like crap.

If Nicole is Mia’s mom then the father is probably Victor. Mia would suddenly be a Kiriakis. Bo and Mia would be siblings. There are even questions about the paternity of Chad. He looks like EJ. If by some weird twist EJ had an illegitimate child and Chad was his son then Grace would be his granddaughter. Grace’s grandparents would be Victor and EJ. I hope Stefano is taking good care of her in the dungeon.



  • http://s6.invisionfree.com/Waiting_for_you/ EJami Obsessed

    Yeah, all signs point this direction but I still hope Mia ia the secret daughter. But ever getting any couple or wish on Days for me has been 0-0.
    I predict that Mia is Nicole’s half-sister and not her daughter. Faye has returned to Salem and I from minute one thought that Mia resembled Nicole.

  • DebbieR

    I was always holding out hope that Nicole was somebody’s mother, but not anymore. When Nicole was finally telling EJ the truth, she said she lost her baby, her only pregnancy. Unless, that is a lie. (imagine that.)

  • dom

    it would kind of make sense though-Melanie’s interest in the health field???? Carly a doctor??
    But, i just dont see Carly and Trent together-BUT-TRENT AND NICOLE, were together, and i bet Melanie is Nicole’s daughter-Now that makes more sense.
    So we will see.
    I am going for Nicole/ Mel
    Carly/Mia

    and i am sure that Zack is going to be coming back soon too-and he will be probably 25years old

  • Pamela J Adkins

    These ppl are actors. Saying that someone “looks” like someone else is stupid. geesh.

  • Rebecca

    I beleive that it is Melanie and Carly due to the medical professions. For some reason even if the child is not raised by the parent they seem to have some of the same traits as the parent.

    Mia and Nicole–OMG that would make a great storyline after the way Nicole screwed Mia over!!!! They would have to work on their relaionship and tha could take years to drag out. Yep!!! That’s a Day’s storyline.

    Off the subject I think Hope needs to go to a clinic for anorexia. People who have eating disorders have to have control of everything. When they lose control then they either strave, puke or cut for control.

  • Stefanie

    I do think that Mia and Nicole are related.. but i think they are sisters…. it would make sense maybe since fay just came back that she had a daughter after Nicole and it was Mia… on the other hand .. i hope that Melanie is Carly’s daughter i think they would act great together… give her some scenes with women instead of all these men.. shes a great actress!!

  • laura

    who’s fay?? i have not seen any one named fay yet.

  • Missy

    Faye is Nicole’s mom….They may be actors, but they try to cast people who look like they could be related for show relatives….The nicole being Mia’s mom after Mia was screwed over by Nicole, well that is Kate and Billie all over agian…No matter who Carly’s daughter is, this story is interesting :)

  • soho

    I could see it- Lawrence giving Carly’s daughter to someone who wasn’t going to treat her well like Trent. Maybe Lawrence and Trent had business/relations/etc in the past. As for who Melanie’s father is… Daniel would be an interesting choice to kinda throw obstacles in his relationship with Chloe.

  • Helena

    I think Mel is Daniel and Carly’s daughter, Lawrence has just sold the girl to Trent/Roscoe Born maybe via Dr Baker (i could see him come back toward january/february).
    Mia and Nicole for me could really be related : i don’t know how maybe as sisters (though Faye will not stay, she is just a guest but she can come back after all when AZ comes back herself from her maternity leave) or maybe as daughter/mother anyway it’s is the case it’s a great potential for a good storyline with all the hate from Mia and the guilt from Nicole…yes this could be a really interesting and ironic twist (and Nicole finally will have a daughter she wants so much lol)
    As for Chad being Ej’s son..i don’t know Ej is really young to be a grand-father but after all Sami is Will’s mother…but still Chad is older than Will and Ej is a little younger than Sami (i know he has been majorly sorased..lol) so i don’t know..but i heard, just a rumor saying Ej could be somehow related to Grace and indeed it’s strange they cast Chad as a very tall, brown eyes/hair guy so i could definitly see them related..maybe Chad is Tony or Andre or Peter (but they have been adopted) so maybe he is another Susan’s son or another Stefano’s son..we will see..

  • LL65

    Could be, I’m also curious about the several discussion betw Maggie and Mia about being a dancer and running off to pursue their dreams. The similarities may be a foreshadowing. So how would Maggie be Mia’s grandmother or relation?

  • katsmommie

    James, you and Amy crack me up. I think all of that is very possible. GrandPa EJ. Ha, ha.

  • carol miller

    More fun reading comments! Actually, everyone in Salem is related to everyone else. . . can you imagine having to draw a family tree!! What an incestuous (and dysfunctional) group we all watch.

  • ollie

    I would find more original for Melanie to be Carly’s and Trent or Daniel’s and for Mia to be Nicole’s sister long lost sibling she never knew about, that would be more interesting. the story would hold more together then then every one ending up having grown up children all of the sudden. As far as chad goes he could be Ej’s and an old flame of his or even Susan and Stephano’s other Son Susan kept secrect from Stefano.

  • Molly Ann

    Someone said something about Lawrence giving Melanie to Trent because he would treat her badly. I thought that Melanie was Trent’s biological father though. Isn’t that why Max went off in search of her? I know that Max is gone now, but wouldn’t it be interesting for Melanie to find out that Max is not her brother and that Carly’s son (is his name Nick?) is? But yeah, I thought that Melanie was Trent’s biological daughter. And what about Max’s biological mother? Do we know anything about her? I’ve only been watching Days about a year and a half, so I don’t know if we know that. But why are we searching for a father for Melanie? Why couldn’t Carly have had the affair with Trent?
    However, I think Melanie being Carly and Daniel’s daughter would be much more interesting. It might cause some problems for Daniel and Chloe. They are WAAAAY too happy together for Days. Haha.

  • Chelsea

    melanie is gonna be carly’s daughter. as for the father, i hope its dr. dan. that’ll throw a wrench in that nasty danloe pairing & i think shawn christian & crystal chappell would be hot together. i think the whole trent adopting her thing could work since he was a cruel bastard & treated her awfully.

  • Collette

    I totally agree with Daniel being the one who could be the father of Carly’s daughter. They both were doctors in other countries it would only make sense that they would have hooked up. Plus, Daniel hooks up with all the beautiful women on Days at one time or another. Plus I read somewhere it was rumored that Carly and Daniel were going to be paired in the future, I am not a fan of them being paired, but maybe this is where the rumor stemmed from and they actually have a daughter together. Before the storyline came out that Carly had an affair with someone at a medical convention, I was holding out hope that it was Bo’s child and that she was pregnant when she left Salem, but that theory went down the tubes. Anyhow, I think it would make sense that Melanie is her daughter, because she was the one all over Europe. I never really believed Trent was her father, because most fathers who love their daughters would not pimp them out for debts they owe. Anyways, it’ll be interesting and I can’t wait to find out. Days is at it’s best right now and I’m enjoying every minute of it!

  • Jean

    I also believe that Mel will be Carly’s daughter, just not enough grief over a lost grandchild for me to believe it’s Mia. I just can’t figure out why she’s not more upset over Mel either, has Bo not at least told her of her daughters past that the man that raised her pimped her out, did he not tell her that he himself wanted to lock her up for killing this man instaed of giving her a medal? Questions, questions!!!
    As for Chad, maybe he is Zack!!!
    Mia, I would love for her mother to be on, I would love for it to be Nicole, of course before her and Will kissed I was all for her being his twin that Stefano had taken at birth. When Sami gave birth to Will Stefano had “amnesia” and was sitting in the hospital waiting room with Marlena so that could have easily happened.

  • Jenn J

    I hope it does turn out in the future that Melanie is Nicole’s daughter and I’m okay with Mia being Carly’s. I just have heartburn…Mia looks nothing like Carly. I know they are actors, but the storyline looks thrown together…Mia being without family and Carly just showing up. Kind of lame. But I really like the Nicole/Melanie angle…I thought it would come out initially when Trent was on, but NOPE. And who does Chad belong to? Everyone is related to someone. I think it’s pretty sure that Chad can’t be related to Rafe like first speculated…because Gabi is going to factor into the Mia/Chad/Will storyline. That would just be gross. :(

  • Heidi

    Don’t worry about baby Grace in the dungeon. Dr. Rolf has an excellent track record with reviving dead people, and has successfully raised children in the dungeon before.

  • Heidi

    It would be ironic if Nicole and Mia were sisters. That would mean that Nicole actually gave up a baby she was related to, and could have kept, to get Sydney instead. If Grace was with Nicole, she probably wouldn’t have been wherever she was when she was exposed to Meningitis and would not have died. Nicole would be happily living with a baby she had a legitimate claim to instead of on the run with one she is doomed to lose.

  • Cherie

    I think Carly’s daughter is Melanie! I was my first thought when she said she had a daughter! Not only that she was marked to be killed and Phillip saved her! Carly’s husband put a hit out on her! I really thought Nicole was her mom! As far as her dad! Trenton was a doctor so he could be the father but with days you know they will turn that around for Daniel to be the father!

    I wouldn’t be surprise if Mia wasn’t Nicole’s at this point! I thought Nicole was pregant with either Eric’s or Victor’s baby at one time and lost it!

    That would mean that Mia & Will are cousins and that’s why the writters didnt take it no further! Now Gabby is moving in on Will!

    Just a few thoughts!

DaysTalk Top Commentors

  1. Kathy Ford (5)
  2. Magicmike527 (1)
  3. Marcia Matthew (1)
  4. Mary Ellen Thurman (1)
  5. Mary K. (1)
  6. Tmg477 (1)

  • Mary K.: Miss Amy & jabee.  Are they on vacation?
  • Kathy Ford: I agree with you Dseubert and I think Rafe is the person who has managed to make her happy for once, They just need to straighten out their problems.
  • Kathy Ford: Sorry about the above post. I got Carrie mixed up with Maddie. But my comment still remains the same. At the same time, I do like the friendship that'

Day of Our Lives Updates - Sign Up Now!

Name:
Email:
Yes! I want to keep up-to-date.
Sign up and receive our 20 second
morning summary.